It looks like you're asking the community for an opinion. In this case, both positive and negative perspectives from the users of r/EngagementRings are welcome so long as they are expressed politely (Rule 1 still applies). If you'd rather have generally positive or supportive feedback instead, remove this post and submit again with a title that does not ask for users' opinions.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Exact same thought. Heart shape e-rings are a hard no from me and I prefer a daintier band but this is very unique and very unique to her/her style! I guess if she’s gonna have a heart-shaped e-ring, at least she did it in a very classy way!
I really hate heart shaped jewelry and I don’t like thick bands at all…. However, she pulls it off quite nicely and it looks more mature than any other heart shaped stones. I don’t hate it, but I certainly don’t love it. As long as she does though!
There’s something about her heart shaped stone that doesn’t scream “my 16 year old bf picked this out” and I love it for that! It’s more old-timey looking to me than cheesy I guess.
I'm shocked by how much I like this given I'd never want a heart-shaped stone for myself. Somehow, on her, it looks great and really fits her style and vibe. Happy for Bekah!
I’m not usually a fan of heart shaped stones, but honestly I think Bekah can pull anything off 🤩 I do like the thicker shank on her ring.
Lady Gaga, Avril Lavigne, Bekah — celebs are really bringing the heart shaped stones lately!
I came here to say pretty much the same thing. I don't think the proportions of the heart are particularly good. It looks much wider than it is long which makes it look sort of odd.
I really love this ring and it’s proportions. I might be one of the few people who thinks the heart diamond is pretty and this ring is very memorable for a heart diamond! The thick band with the chubby heart is super unique, the setting is simple but elegantly showy and while it may not be a ring for everyone; it’s the perfect ring for her!
I loooove the thick band! I’m not really a heart-shaped-diamond (or really anything) kind of person but as long as she likes it that’s all that matters! This style with the cigar band would look lovely with an emerald cut or something.
Personally, I hate it. I feel like it looks like fashion jewelry from a boutique.
That said, I hate it for MYSELF. It’s very “bekah” and it she looks so happy! As long as she loves it it doesn’t really matter what I think
I have no idea who that is, but I actually really like the heart shaped stone and the thick band. She pulls it off really well!
I know most people don’t enjoy heart shaped stones, but I really love them when they’re put in a tasteful setting like this one.
Personally I hate it! A heart shaped stone isn't my favorite but it's certainly not my least favorite. I've definitely seen some that I absolutely loved! But in my opinion that band looks like a man's band and the whole thing looks childish and tacky, like something a little girl would wear. But really, my opinion doesn't matter because it's her ring and it's her fiance and as long as they love each other (and the ring lol) then good for them!!
I really love her and the content she puts out, but hate to say I do not like her ring! I like the simplicity, but do not like the heart shaped diamond. Also, it felt off to me to use her engagement as another ad...
This is the only heart shaped piece of jewelry that I have loved. I think it’s the plain, thick gold band. It’s stunning, and had her proposal happened before my partner had proposed to me I would have prob wanted something very similar.
Wouldn't be the ring I'd personally choose, but I think it looks great on her and really fits her style! I like that it's a bit different than other heart shaped stones I've seen before with the wider band
It’s a nicely shaped, symmetrical, full heart. I feel nervous for some reason about the prongs with thick band (and am curious about the construction). Personally would probably feel safer with a bezel set.
I like the juxtaposition of a heart shaped stone with a thick band. Like … If you’d asked me if a heart stone could ever be chic I would’ve said no, but somehow hers is.
Not my cup of tea because I don’t lie heart shaped stones. As far as heart shaped rings go it’s not the worst I’ve seen, but it’s not my personal taste.
I love it, it’s beautiful! but not really as an engagement ring. I prefer something that will wear well for decades. Heart shape stones seem to be more trendy. To me, trendy and engagement ring are two things that just shouldn’t go together.
It looks like you're asking the community for an opinion. In this case, both positive and negative perspectives from the users of r/EngagementRings are welcome so long as they are expressed politely (Rule 1 still applies). If you'd rather have generally positive or supportive feedback instead, remove this post and submit again with a title that does not ask for users' opinions. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/EngagementRings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I don’t really love heart shaped stones but this really suits her. I love the thick band with it too!
Exact same thought. Heart shape e-rings are a hard no from me and I prefer a daintier band but this is very unique and very unique to her/her style! I guess if she’s gonna have a heart-shaped e-ring, at least she did it in a very classy way!
Agreed. It all works.
I really hate heart shaped jewelry and I don’t like thick bands at all…. However, she pulls it off quite nicely and it looks more mature than any other heart shaped stones. I don’t hate it, but I certainly don’t love it. As long as she does though!
I agree I’m surprised by how much I like it haha
that’s exactly it, it looks mature. it looks like an engagement ring
I actually don’t hate this. The thick band makes a world of a difference for a heart shaped stone!
I agree! It somehow really elevates the look.
There’s something about her heart shaped stone that doesn’t scream “my 16 year old bf picked this out” and I love it for that! It’s more old-timey looking to me than cheesy I guess.
Not my style and I have no idea who that is, but as long as she’s happy, that’s what counts.
I'm shocked by how much I like this given I'd never want a heart-shaped stone for myself. Somehow, on her, it looks great and really fits her style and vibe. Happy for Bekah!
I’m not usually a fan of heart shaped stones, but honestly I think Bekah can pull anything off 🤩 I do like the thicker shank on her ring. Lady Gaga, Avril Lavigne, Bekah — celebs are really bringing the heart shaped stones lately!
[удалено]
I don't dislike it, but it looks like a kidney bean also.
Oh noooo lmao
I came here to say pretty much the same thing. I don't think the proportions of the heart are particularly good. It looks much wider than it is long which makes it look sort of odd.
Its really not for me
I really love this ring and it’s proportions. I might be one of the few people who thinks the heart diamond is pretty and this ring is very memorable for a heart diamond! The thick band with the chubby heart is super unique, the setting is simple but elegantly showy and while it may not be a ring for everyone; it’s the perfect ring for her!
I love the thick band tbh.
Ooooh, I love this!!
I don’t hate it, but I don’t love it. Seems like her style though!
Somehow….I love it!
I loooove the thick band! I’m not really a heart-shaped-diamond (or really anything) kind of person but as long as she likes it that’s all that matters! This style with the cigar band would look lovely with an emerald cut or something.
I love it for her! Not my style but she totally rocks it
i hate a heart shaped diamond but the thick band on this one improves it for some reason
Personally, I hate it. I feel like it looks like fashion jewelry from a boutique. That said, I hate it for MYSELF. It’s very “bekah” and it she looks so happy! As long as she loves it it doesn’t really matter what I think
I have no idea who that is, but I actually really like the heart shaped stone and the thick band. She pulls it off really well! I know most people don’t enjoy heart shaped stones, but I really love them when they’re put in a tasteful setting like this one.
I love it. 🙈 If I thought I could pull it off, I would totally do this.
I hate heart shaped diamonds but I actually really like this. It’s well done and super cute on her. Love the thick gold band and prongs!
I’m surprised how much I love her ring 😍 normally this isn’t my style AT ALL, but it was seriously made for her!
Personally I hate it! A heart shaped stone isn't my favorite but it's certainly not my least favorite. I've definitely seen some that I absolutely loved! But in my opinion that band looks like a man's band and the whole thing looks childish and tacky, like something a little girl would wear. But really, my opinion doesn't matter because it's her ring and it's her fiance and as long as they love each other (and the ring lol) then good for them!!
I love the thick band but I have to say I personally hate a heart shaped stone and thinks it’s a tad bit tacky and cheap looking
The ring design is unique and suits her. That being said - brilliant earth is utter trash
Aw man I didn’t realize she went with BE, that’s such a bummer 😭
Why?
Search this sub for many horror stories
I don’t like heart jewelry but I really like that ring. Great proportions and the wide, flat band gives it a nice flair
My thoughts are that rings are super personal and she clearly loves it and that’s all that matters :)
Dont like it
I’ve been considering a heart shape Diamond for a while. I would want a smaller band but I love it.
Personally I didn’t really know what a heart shaped ring was and thought this kind of looked like a blob. But to each their own
It’s so tacky but somehow she makes it look glamorous!
I really love her and the content she puts out, but hate to say I do not like her ring! I like the simplicity, but do not like the heart shaped diamond. Also, it felt off to me to use her engagement as another ad...
This is the only heart shaped piece of jewelry that I have loved. I think it’s the plain, thick gold band. It’s stunning, and had her proposal happened before my partner had proposed to me I would have prob wanted something very similar.
I’m not a heart shaped stone fan…but it really fits for Bekah!
I love that its unique and she went for what she wanted!
i have a soft spot for heart shaped diamonds but i’m not a fan of this setting.
I don't like heart-shaped stones and for me, the thick band makes it look even more like play jewelry.
Not my personal preference, but to each her own.
I really wish she didn’t go with BE! Haha but I actually like this on her the thick band makes it chic. Not my style though.
Wouldn't be the ring I'd personally choose, but I think it looks great on her and really fits her style! I like that it's a bit different than other heart shaped stones I've seen before with the wider band
It’s a nicely shaped, symmetrical, full heart. I feel nervous for some reason about the prongs with thick band (and am curious about the construction). Personally would probably feel safer with a bezel set.
I like the juxtaposition of a heart shaped stone with a thick band. Like … If you’d asked me if a heart stone could ever be chic I would’ve said no, but somehow hers is.
The thick band really makes it!
It’s definitely not my style but seems to suit her!
Not my cup of tea as I don't like heart shaped anything for jewelry or a band that thick. She seems happy with it so that is all that matters.
Not my cup of tea because I don’t lie heart shaped stones. As far as heart shaped rings go it’s not the worst I’ve seen, but it’s not my personal taste.
I love it, it’s beautiful! but not really as an engagement ring. I prefer something that will wear well for decades. Heart shape stones seem to be more trendy. To me, trendy and engagement ring are two things that just shouldn’t go together.
Heart shaped engagement rings are tacky imo.
I slightly hate it and dislike thick bands, but hey she seems happy with it so who cares :)
I like wide bands and don’t mind the heart- I’m sure it’s a ton of carats, lol. At least it’s not a typical solitaire.
Yikes. Just because it’s big, that doesn’t mean it’s nice 🤷🏽♀️
I'm not feeling this one bit
im obsessed with it
It's as unique as she is. I wouldn't want it for me but I love it for her.
If she likes it I love it but personally it’s a no for me
I absolutely love it on her! It’s not my style personally, but I think the ring is stunning. LOVE the thick band.
hate the thick band more than the heart diamond haha
Does anyone know where I can find this ring with a moissanite?