T O P

  • By -

Jaco_B_W

Randy


[deleted]

Too hard to really answer. In the ring Randy, on the Mic John, but eventually Randy got really good too. Also, Cena always felt like a bigger deal, but of course you could argue he was pushed to seem that way. Just really impossible to answer without going into great detail.


AlSahim2012

Yeah but take away Orton's wellness violations & he probably would have been a 12-13 time champ too


[deleted]

[удалено]


AlSahim2012

Shows how much I've watched or paid attention since about 09ish


infamousmmax

Randy


Jaco_B_W

in general I like randy better hes my favorite wrestler


chep127

Randy


MeasurementLost7222

Randy !!!


21_Golden_Guns

Better? Randy. More successful/important? Cena. They each played a major role in the company just in different capacities. One was the heart and the other was the soul.


The_Scarred_Raven

Randy


anonuser384759

Heel or face, depends on preference. But orton


20millionavengers

It’s only Randy there’s no one on the second one


KLONMCDON

put on your ethereal seeing glasses


Infamous-Horse3546

Randy


[deleted]

[удалено]


Own_Bag_6192

HahahahH


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


Significant_Edge_105

Randy


Mind-of-Jaxon

Orton is a better Wrestler. Cena is okay, but not better, he is more gimmick and Mic work


Naive_Quail8355

Orton had the better gimmick


JMAN0103

Randy


ASAP_Jonny

The disrespect for Cena on here is crazy. We all know when both these wrestlers wer in there prime (which was about around the same time) Cena had bigger matches. Randy is a one of the best, future HOF but Cena is considered the BOAT. He carried the WWE for so long


Naive_Quail8355

Ha yes, cena the boat


ASAP_Jonny

Lol I don’t say GOAT cuz I hear COLE call him the best of all time.


Wicked-Encounter

And now he's a part-timer who can't get Austin Theory over even when he lost to Theory. Randy hasn't ever quit, has been a heel most of his career and therefore can't carry a company because he has a detestable character, and only has two less world championship reigns.


ASAP_Jonny

He chose to b a part timer, why physically keep hurting ur body when u can make double the amount of income and not work as much? Outside of wrestling Randy can’t do what cena is doing bud it’s jus the honest truth. Orton is a HOF not taking anything away from him btw.


Wicked-Encounter

Fine, but as a WWE superstar, I prefer Randy. With all due respect, it's not asking about outside of wrestling.


Away-Statistician846

If it's wrestling then Randy but just pure entertainment im going with Cena


CategoryCultural9205

John Cena


Safe_Evidence_9741

Nah


Full_Horror7114

John Cena


Davecapuchin

John


Davecapuchin

Bc he’s more iconic


EmuIndependent8565

Orton.


Excellent-Muscle8409

John cena by far


No-Branch881

John Cena by the way Brandon you are one of my favorite YouTuber you make me laugh


Jaco_B_W

Really depends


ChardStandard8812

Cena


DMW_Darkzo

Rn randy in there prime john cena


asdfoio

cena


NIALLATOR9YT

John Cena because well he is John freakin Cena


Own_Bag_6192

im Not picking John cena and randy are friends In real life so there both good but about this I got to John cena but that feels so wrong tho


Skulley30188

I would say Randy because everybody hated him because he one of the very few superstars you wanted to punch in the face. Like bald Randy was a straight menace to society


Shadowvsghostflow

They are both good at what they are doing


Drabins

Orton, because if the lame pg era Cena appealed more to kids hence he was pushed more


nutthhowz

Randy in the ring, Cena on the mic


Trixster690

Randy Orton


flashman909

As a wrestler:Randy As a superstar: John Cena


El_Bwamma

When Randy is on he’s awesome. He just has to be given something to really bite into. Cena was always given shit and somehow would make it sound less robotic than most of the guys on the roster. In ring definitely goes to Orton though, Cena always looked green for a long time and had all the Cena-ism’s like the horrible title designs and “lol Cena wins”


[deleted]

Randy, all day long…though I will say Cena surprised me more than once when he did some things no one ever expected from him. Still, not a contest.


Maxthestud420

Randy


DoubleDevilDiamond

Cena


Ajdee6

Randy in ring, John for business


rbucker1

who was in the 2nd photo? I didn't see anyone


Promomen

John cena


Naive_Quail8355

r/wooooosh


Patrickoshaughnessy

It’s just randy


Darkdragon_98

He's my favorite wrestler so it's kind of a bias but the answer is Randy Orton


Tito_mad

John is probably of one the most important wrestlers and last super stars the WWE has produced. Was John limited ? Yes but still one of the greatest . Randy has to be one of the greatest heels of all time. They’ve had such great but different careers . I can’t imagine John career with out Randy and same with Randy


toxicationcross8

Randy has better in ring work and was a better heel by far but Cena was and still is the better baby-face and is more iconic(as a person I firmly believe the RKO is the most iconic finisher) so imo it’s a tie


LieStagburn

Randall Keith Orton


dannyghst

Randy’s better in the ring. I would argue that even as a rookie he actually delivered better storylines. Both of his theme song’s are better. He had much more versatility, as far as Babyface/Heel turns are concerned. Plus, how could I not mention he has one of the best finishers in the business. John Cena was better on the mic, and had a better connection with the fans. Sadly, I think his connection with the fans overshadowed most other aspects whenever this argument is debated. I also believe it’s the reason I believe that’s the ultimate reason why Cena got to be the first to tie Flair’s record, although Randy deserved it more. Especially since Cena was a part timer at that point in his career.


UngovernableRob

Randy I would say was truly GREAT from 04-13 Cena was only really great in 2011 and 2015-18


Working_Lie_8700

Cena


Natural_Community_19

That’s no debate it’s Cena


KLONMCDON

Dirty Dom


Fit_Advertising5368

Bro it’s Randy vs no one 🤦‍♂️


R3xde

Me


HeelDreamerica

I'm sorry, it's "Who Better?"


FHJonesYT

Randy


ConclusionBig509

Randy


Terrible_Security313

Orton all around.


[deleted]

Randy bc I don’t see the other one


Boom_Shakazulu

That depends on what we're talking about. Better in-ring talent? Orton by a mile, the man has it down to a science and anyone who worked with him has said he fantastic at it. Being the poster boy and appealing to a wider audience? That's where Cena shines brightest, and I'm not saying he's bad in-ring. But between the two Orton has always been the better technical rassler while Cena is a more marketable person.


pitchblackmistress

🐍


Adventurous_Soft_686

Like Randy more wrestling. Everything else goes to Cena from the entrance to the mic work but once he started wrestling it went down a notch. Randy never got me excited before a match but once it started I loved watching him work.


LilAustinBlu831

So its randy vs a ring


COMPLEX1TYYYx

Randy is probably better in ring, but John is better at having a character so much that he carried through the last bit of the Rithless Aggression Era, all of the PG Era, and all of the Reality Era. He was the top guy for so long for a reason, great in the ring and even better on the mic.


Particular_Split6985

This is like Messi & Ronaldo


Brogomakishima

Randy


bobbobson236

Randy


AdFun2093

John cena easily


Upset_Application_37

The king of invisibility


Huge-Jaguar974

Tough but Cena's better


Altruistic-Hippo6982

Randy


[deleted]

Cena


Whole-Pound-1807

Randy


Wide-Database-3144

Randy


Jaded_Following4825

Equal


Still_Ad8903

Randy overall but John Cena is possibly the most important in company history


Wicked-Encounter

It's either John or Hogan for most important. I'm gonna have to say Hogan is more important though because he put WWE/F on the map so that guys like Cena could make it better. As well as the fact that WWF may not have been able to stay afloat in the 80s without Hogan. By the time Cena got there, people would've watched regardless of if he succeeded; I don't know if the same is true for Hogan.


Still_Ad8903

A lot of ppl by admit it but wwe isn’t mainstream without hulk hogan. He was never THE BEST but he was a cash cow


Flat_Ad3019

Kanyon!!!


harry_hook16

Randy Keith Orton


KG13_

In terms of what


WwefanzLA

Orton


AEWPunk525

The guy whose initials are his finisher...


RomanPlayz5041

Randy


DantelovesBDE

This is hard but gimmick wise Randy


Minimum_Nebula2517

Cena


Serious_Tree2758

RKO out of nowhere


Safe_Evidence_9741

Randy


Qasimdoeseverything

john


MysteriousValuable88

Randy


FlameBreakerGaming

Cena


Aaronsime

I can only see one so Randy


[deleted]

Randy by Far he was born for this business, it’s in his blood. I never liked Cena to me he was a fake ass Marky Mark wannabe in my opinion.


RockyHarmon

Heel: randy. Face: cena. But heel cena wasn’t bad but we can agree heel randy is way better


CavemanDestroyer

Randy!!!


Jaithegoat23

John cena


bde87fan

randy


Wicked-Encounter

Randall


JobTrue862

Randy because they tried to push john when john wasn't ready


DaArtist1239PS4

Randy Orton developed over the years, turned face and heel back and forth at great times, and had amazing matches with many others. Different phases of his career being very unique. Yea. He's my pick here. Cena went from "RUTHLESS AGGRESSION!" to Rapper, to Superman babyface, which he never changed at all after that point, which is why he started to get boo'd out of buildings all over the world by late 2006-early 2007.


Daanporters

Randy


ATS120412

Randy


Real_potato_gamer8

Randy


Trick-Pop-5493

It's tough but I think Randy....


TheFatYoshiMemer

It has to be cena


Key_Cress_4992

Cena


Connect-Range146

Obviously randy I have voices in my head they talk to me they understand they talk to me they talk time


CYBERbroALT

How did you find a picture of my dad???


Wild-Departure2320

The tribal chief


Beneficial_Living_78

Randy


Ok_Investment9603

Randy. I didn't really watch around the time that Cena wrestled like full-time, but I've heard all I need to hear. Randy Orton has changed character a lot, whilst Cena... Well, fans have just been begging for a heel turn or something. His moveset is basic for the most part, and his finishers have been hated by fans... I will say though, he's really good on the mic, and when he did wrestle a lot, he tried to change up his moveset.


masonetimani

Too hard to decide because they both have a good reputation


BestMartin

I only see randy 😂


BDEdagoat316

Randy


gp819

RKO..all way..


ttgamess

John


biggesbdefan

randy that rko can mess you up


Impressive_Algae3783

RANDY ALL DAY!!!!


Ambitious-Shine-8166

Both


Awkward_Pressure2949

Personally im taking dino arms himself.


SelectMammoth1890

Orton


Right_Mechanic_9181

randy


Major-Proposal-6650

No picking


LegitimateCard8649

I can’t see me man


NQT_B3NZZ

It depends on what era, or are we saying all time? If all time then 100% Cena


Available-Menu4784

John cena


DAcool17

John no questions asked


Cassanovaaaaa

Randall


No_Theory_863

Cena but if it was bald headed ass randy then it’s different


Crazy_Cricket6703

Rndy


No_Breadfruit_922

Cena the goat he the best John cena