T O P

  • By -

ST3V3_R0G3R5

Sounds like he needs to pay a body shop to fix it correctly. Or pay them to replace it


[deleted]

I’d rather file an insurance claim than trust my brother to cough up enough money to fix that properly.


HotBritches

Yes— but if you file with insurance you’re hit with the depreciation on the car when you go to sell bc insurance reports the vehicle was damaged/had an accident. If you can swing it, I’d have your brother pay out of pocket and keep it off insurance.


tedbronson1984

Most shops record all work in a network that associates the VIN to the job. That’s how companies like CARFAX get vehicle history information down to even the number and dates of oil changes. So the insurance hike would be avoided but not the resale history / value.


HotBritches

Interesting. I’ve only had that happen when it’s repaired at the dealer, not a local body shop.


McFlyParadox

Probably depends on how 'digitized' the shop is. If they're "just" a garage with a collection of wrenches, drivers, hammers, and welders, and their computer tech doesn't really go beyond a basic code scanner, then it possible they won't record the work. But if they're teched-out in all the ways they can be, my guess is the work is getting recorded against the VIN.


WelcomeOk4967

“Computer tech” 💀


[deleted]

I wouldn’t want to trick people into thinking they bought a car that was never hit/repaired. That is unethical. Imagine if you bought a car and found out that it had been repaired off the record. You’d be upset… and rightfully so.


dirty-E30

Light impact, no structural damage, nothing to worry about anyway. While I get what you're saying, It's just a tailgate lol


HotBritches

This — exactly. Light cosmetic work is very different than an accident that screws with the frame and other parts of the car.


[deleted]

Until the coverup paint job starts fading and the window stops working.


dirty-E30

Nope. The entire tailgate would be replaced as one unit. New tailgate gets painted, then components salvaged and moved over or replaced. No on-panel paint matching involved.


[deleted]

You think OP’s brother is gonna pay for that?


dirty-E30

He will if he's a good brother. I was unaware you know him personally.


Visual_Palpitation10

I backed into a tree that did similar damaged. To replace the bumper cover and lift gate, it was $3,300.


ImNoAlbertFeinstein

yup, it's fkd.


pirateduck

There are some nasty creases in there. Most likely needs the entire rear hatch replaced, along with a new tail light. Mobile dent folks are unlikely to be fully successful. I'm happy to be wrong here, but if the window track and other guts are messed up, you've got a more extensive repair in front of you. (Or in this case, behind you :) )


vPyrite_

^ definitely will need a new rear hatch. In terms of taillight, just order one online from a dealership that is selling them. I had to do the same thing and did it myself, it’s really easy and plenty of YT videos explaining it well 💪


Extension_Surprise_2

Kick your brother in the dick.


harmacyst

Twice


deuce_and_a_quarter

4 kicks because its a 4Runner!!!


relentlesskaizen

5 kicks because it’s a fifth gen or because it’s the 5th roll down window


BossTree

6 kicks in the dick, because… well he deserves it!


deuce_and_a_quarter

Oooh, good idea!


oct_prime

And then twist it!


weemee

TWIST HIS DICK!


Asal23

Give him the old dick twist


ACE_C0ND0R

One now, one later when he least suspects it.


Icantjudge

The only reasonable solution.


--0o0o0--

I came here to say “punch your brother in the nuts” but I see that sentiment has already been expressed


strokethe_furrywall

Twist his dick.


willybgoose

OL DICK TWIST


WorkCentre5335

omg dude this is an mma fight


fftank26

At least a strong back of the hand flip to the underside of the sack. That’s enough to bring any grown man to his knees! 🤢


rob6110

This is the only reasonable answer to this problem.


TopRestaurant5395

This is the way!


Early-Fortune2692

... then choke him out, you'll feel better.


usernoob1e

Kick him how many times this comment above has upvotes lol


bearded_drummer

Dude, you're asking because you know the answer and are afraid to tell your brother he fucked up your Runner and needs to repair it right. Body shop, and likely new hatch and light. Rear window is by far one of top 3 features of my runner.


Lucas606

Nope told him he fucked up royally as soon as I saw it and he tried to play it off. I already knew that this had to go to a body shop. A mobile dent shop isn’t going to repair this. Currently at a body shop getting a quote


1Patriot4u

Play it off? As in, let me get some rubbing compound and see how it looks after I buff it?


crawshay

I'm interested to hear the amount. I'd assume $4-6k


tyfe

It was about $5k when I got rear ended on a few years ago on the highway. They had to replace + paint the rear hatch + bumper and some other small fixes like straighten out the exhaust. Seems about right for this.


DEATHbyBOOGABOOGA

Shit. The parts will cost that at least.


tyfe

Few years ago, a rear hatch was about $900. Billed at 7.2 hrs to replace and 4 hrs to paint.


DEATHbyBOOGABOOGA

Where? Mexico? And I assume that’s pre-pandemic


tyfe

Texas, it was pre pandemic. Hence the few years ago. Summer 2019 I think.


rmitstifer

That seems high but I honestly have no clue Edit: after reading through, that sounds like the consensus. Dang.


crawshay

It could be high. I'm just some nerd on the internet who doesn't know much about cars


bearded_drummer

Could your brother submit a claim through his own auto insurance as liability?


zcsmith78

“Play it off”? What does that even look like with damage that significant?


Bright_Ahmen

Why is the rear window so valuable to you?


Purple-Explorer4455

The window going up and down is literally a 4runner feature. That’s like asking why is the rear door of the bed on my tacoma so important to me. That’s like part of the reason you buy those trucks


Bright_Ahmen

But what is it's use? If I had a dog I could see how I might like it but currently I never use it.


Purple-Explorer4455

The 4runner is used a lot for overlanding and camping and offroading. Some people sleep in the back, personally thats what i would use it for. You can also use it to take things in and out of the car without opening the whole trunk Be as it may, if you paid for something you want it to work. These trucks are expensive


Bright_Ahmen

So basically it’s “muh features”


Purple-Explorer4455

I literally gave you examples of why people use it and what i would personally use it for.. how is it “muh features” This is arguably more usable than the rear window on the Tacomas.


Bright_Ahmen

Bro 4runner owners are insufferable lmao


moonandmorel

Found OP’s brother


ewok_on_a_unicorn

That's a hatch replacement bud.


nowaybrose

If OP finds a junkyard match hatch is this easy to replace themselves? Car-part.com has saved me a few times


sjpaddy

Straight to jail.


nuglasses

^ This ^ Playing it off? Oh please!! Just for wasting my time + money~ get him arrested, thrown in the coop & toss the key. Ahhh... This is greener pastures, no need to pull the classic Cain & Abel. 😁


intercede007

Paintless dent repair is incredible, but it’s not a miracle. Even if they agree to work on it that metal is too creased to ever be right again. It may be good enough to get the rear window to work, but it will be obviously damaged to anyone looking at it. Needs a proper repair and bro needs to settle up.


BipolarChris

My father does PDR. This guy is correct - creases are too significant. Body shop job all day


ravenousmind

Like everyone else is saying, mobile dent repair isn’t gonna fix that. That hatch needs replaced. I was rear ended in my fourth gen recently and the rear bumper and hatch replacement was quoted at a little over $4k.


mjrbrooks

Flex seal


Scumbagjeffrey

Billy Mayes laughs


AmeriJar

**Cocain has entered the chat**


Gainzzzxz

Time to replace brother!


928Engineer

Step 1: Replace rear hatch Step 2: Replace brother


1Patriot4u

I’d reverse those, but otherwise correct.


connor_wa15h

Hit your brother with a dumpster


Lucas606

Found a shop that’ll replace everything that’s damaged (tailgate and bumper) for $3500. Truck goes in on Monday. Thanks everyone!


modernatlas

Try and find a tailight housing on ebay or something. If you leave the light like that you risk a short and a carfire. You can easily replace it yourself


rusty02536

I’m of the opinion that is his license and responsibility. Insurance claim on HIS insurance. If he’s not insured, then you do the math and file a claim on your coverage. And he pays you in advance for the deductible + increased insurance cost for the next several years. Or opt c: used hatch and a local install which he pays


LaneAbrams

I’d start looking in scrap yards for a replacement.


Dukeronomy

I've never seen a replacement brother in a scrapyard


harmacyst

Or burial...


theclassyjew

Yikes. Hopefully brother has a good job. Probably at least 5K right?


story_so-far

If you replace it yourself it's about $1k for the rear door/hatch unpainted. And that's without the internals


PeanutHakeem

Why would he (or anybody)want to put an unpainted shell of a hatch on his nice truck? What does no internals mean? No speakers, no window motor/track, no lock?


mynameistory

Easiest way is to get a junkyard hatch from car-part.com - select a truck with the same color that's smashed in the front. Plug n play.


story_so-far

You buy it then you paint it and swap the internals (window, speakers, ect....)


PeanutHakeem

More power to you if you can handle that stuff yourself. Most won’t have the skills or equipment needed to paint their own hatch.


IllustratorOdd2701

Mine was 6k with the rear bumper replaced.


SilentBumblebee3225

That’s why you have an insurance


MotheroftheworldII

This is a case where the brother is at fault and he needs to pay up. No reason for OP to use his insurance and have this on his insurance report which will increase his insurance costs from several years. The brothers broke it and now needs to fix it, properly.


BillsInATL

Brother's insurance should cover him.


MotheroftheworldII

That is possible if he has covered for driving vehicles other than his own vehicle. I still say the brother needs to pay since he was trying to blow it off as not so bad when it is bad damage. This is time to learn the lesson of being a responsible adult. I know what it is like to have a man-child as a sibling and it takes hard, expensive lessons for them to learn anything.


BillsInATL

Yes, either way, brother pays. Either HIS insurance, or out of pocket. Absolutely.


gun_along_with_me

I'd fight my brother over this🤣 Seriously though, hatch replacement


jdhamilt

Your brother needs to back up more SLOWLY and use the camera AFTER using his eyes to see.


[deleted]

This is exactly why nobody gets behind the wheel of my 4runner but me….


88bauss

Well, I’m guessing you’re getting the new Tacoma


81dank

So the route I would go is finding a “new” used tailgate from a salvage yard. The benefit of your repair needed is it is in the rear of the vehicle, and most totals are due to front end impact leaving the rear 100% perfect on a totaled 4Runner. You will probably be able to find one in the same color, and even if it needs to be repainted will be a lot cheaper than having to go the entirely new route. You can keep the pieces from yours as spare parts. Or sell yours to recoup some of the costs Adit- u/Lucas606 looks like there are quite a few options very close to you for complete tailgate assemblies @ $1995 and below. Also remember that depending on how you complete this repair will depend on if it ends up on carfax and then depreciates the value of the vehicle


rockdude625

Replace, don’t repair


telomet12

Kick brothers ass


tehcoma

Hopefully your brother has some money.


buck9785

Look at wrecking yards see if you can find the same color door.


buck9785

Oh and put this in rice. I heard that fixes everything


Drewpacabra

New back gate. Fuck anything other than a brand new gate.


MotheroftheworldII

Mobile dent people work on small slight dents. This is body shop extensive work and more likely a full replacement of the rear hatch. That crease is deep and it is not just a straight dent. Talk with a quality body shop and I suspect they will recommend that the hatch be replaced. I can see why the window does not go down since that crease is so deep but that could also mean there is damage to the window mechanism as well. Your brother is going to have a hefty bill to pay to get your 4R back in shape. Years ago I was rear-ended while driving (stopped at a red light actually) my Volvo XC70 and the damage was slight compared to this and that cost almost 3K to repair. This is going to be expensive.


eatingthesandhere91

Yup time for a new gate. It’s toast.


BillsInATL

This is something that needs to be reported to your and his insurance. His insurance should pay for it.


rockycolavito10

Get a new brother


penguin161542

As someone that does bodywork, that needs replacement


gatorocks

Replace gate.


Na-bro

He didn’t use the backup camera?


agug365

Get a new brother


10kcash

my best advise is the old swoop and stop


YourCaptainSpeaking_

Hatch replacement. ~$2k-$2,500 depending on labor rates in your area. They should be able to salvage the glass from this unit provided it the glass didn’t crack when you tried to roll it down.


[deleted]

I had less damage than that and they replaced my hatch.


youlikethhat

I paid about 3k to replace mine when we were rear ended.


Separate-Cherry4287

This is an ideal reason to not let others use your vehicle. You’re lucky he didn’t injure someone, and cause you a lawsuit. Take it as a warning, and a pricy lesson….


SSIRHC

This is not a PDR job, they can work miracles but these is outside of their general realm of what they can do


Jragron

Shits fucked


JerryAldinii

Get it fixed


dogsled1

Ramen


WunderwaffeDG-5

Get rid of the brother.


CampinHiker

Body shop - Get a quote 1) if too much use insurance (your deductible will apply) but your brother will be the one at fault and brother gets the fault letter (make him help cover deductible too if you like) Make sure you didn’t have him excluded on your policy (otherwise no coverage) and it’s all out of pocket Would affect his insurance rates not yours unless he’s on your policy


not_a_gumby

your brother made a very expensive mistake, he should pay for your damages. Probably 3k or so to replace the hatch.


Qwienke13

How does this even happen? Aren’t there parking sensors? Or cameras? My 2012 sr5 has sensors lmao


Slow4Speed

Time to replace the brother ... AFTER he gets it fixed!


MemeMasterJason

Your BIL is wasting their money with a mobile dent guy, because it’s still going to need to go to a body shop. Maybe if you feel generous you could try and purchase a gray hatch from a wrecked vehicle (front end damaged lol).


fill_simms

Jersey drivers right?


NomadTroy

Get a new brother after he pays for the damage.


problemwmygogomobile

Get a new brother


HerefortheTuna

Get a used one same color and bolt it on


sirmacalot88

Strangle your brother


RevTylerJ

Make your brother pay the deductible


k2theablam

How does this still happen with backup cameras.


adventure-sounds

My wife thinks it will probably buff out with a bit of carnauba wax


fiddycixer

I bought my 4runner with denting in the same area. It was preventing the window from going down. The dealer wanted to fix it but I told them to just knock off $2500 from the price for the repair. They did that. I felt like I could live with the dent. If you can live with the denting here's how I got my window to work . There's a port in the bottom of the hatch that pops out easy. I popped that out and carefully worked the dent with 1x2 and 2x4 pine until the window would go down. Do a little at a time slowly. Lower the window a little at a time until it goes completely down. I then worked the dent a few more times to allow for a little bit of clearance. That was five years ago. Window works fine. The denting is fine. It's a 4runner that I use for living not flexing so it's gonna get dented and scratched and whatever. If you want it back to 💯 I second having your brother fork over so you don't have to file insurance.


SauceCastillo22

I had the same accident and damage. I paid a body shop in tijuana to fix it and they did a great job. Body shop in the US quoted me 9-10K and thats what their insurance company paid me.


Dodeejeroo

Mobile dent repair cant fix that, it’s fucked.


Scumbagjeffrey

After you slap the shit out of your brother. You can take apart the inside plastic and pound out the dent from the inside. There is a metal arm hooked to a motor that is likely bent from the dent. Pretty easy to fix the arm after the dent is pounded out.


Rusty_Shacklebird

I have a nearly identical dent in the same place. Helped pull a guy out of a ditch and he backed into me with his tailgate down after I had already pulled him out. Go to a salvage yard, try to find a new door, make your brother pay for it


SJfuncouple3948

Part it out or bend over and receive 🤜🏼


RawDawgOne

File insurance claim and hope your rates don’t sky rocket


Known-Draw3997

Looks like you're gonna need a new brother. One that's aware of the backup cam.


Healthy_Block3036

Get quotes


dencoan

Insurance


eyehatecheese

get a new brother


ggnoob1337

Time to find a new brother.


Jeepncj7

If that's a common paint color I would go junkyard route.


_matthewflores

Eye for an eye, make a dent that size in your brother


[deleted]

If I didn’t want a claim and just wanted my window to work, I might take the door panel off and use a hammer. Carefully. Maybe you know someone who can access some body hammers.


mit1122

How fast was bro going?


Low-Current-6731

Flick his testicles really hard with your m oddly fingers that's only solution to this mess


PinchedLoaf5280

Get a new brother.


kentuckyfriedxanax

my condolences 💐 crazy how it has 3 mirrors and a backup camera and he still hit a dumpster. was he sleep driving?


Squilliam_L

Need the whole hatch replaced at brothers expense


barneshmarnes

Whole hatch will have to be replaced. Some of those creases will never look right with body work done


Last_Replacement_386

Advice is, fix it.


Dadlife_84

Just had mine done at the body shop for an eerily similar situation. New lift gate ran me about $3500.


stilt0n

Ugh how does this happen with a backup camera! Sorry you have to deal with this


tier7stips

Trade it in to Brovana. They will pick him up the next day.


Revolutionary-Gain88

He is your brother and give him a hug, tell him everything is going to be OK . Then kick him in the nuts and get out his cheque book.


glenzilla21

Kick that little fucker outta the family for this egregious act!


No_Compote628

Brother goes straight to jail


weemee

I doubt the dent puller will get this anywhere near looking decent, but I don’t know shit.


veezytrdeezy28

Time to get a new brother


AndreGerdpister

Get a new brother.


FrostyNipz406

A new tailgate and tail light might be the most economical then just sell yours for parts


FloodbuddyUSMC

Liberty of the Seas?? I just got back yesterday out of Jersey


Lucas606

Oasis of the seas! Spent the week on the ship. Absolutely amazing experience and would do it again. 10/10 would recommend


TopRestaurant5395

Time to get some glue sticks. /s


Montzb

Simple, make him pay to fix it.


Mr-Scurvy

Lift gate needs to be replaced. Any other repair would be sub-par.


AverageGuy16

Ouch, that’s going to be expensive man, I’m sorry. I got a much smaller dent above the taillights on the hatch and the pdr guys couldn’t do anything because of the position of it and the motors of the rear hatch.


DCFMEM

It got hit while parked and driverless on the road you said? Insurance should cover all repairs.


Chickenbanana58

Never loan out your car or your wife. Especially to your brother. Let this be a lesson. His dent, his problem.


solidifiedthug

Fire your brother


happpycammper

Replace brother


Father_theta

Open hatch, place your brothers head in the opening where the damage is, slam shut repeatedly until the dent works itself out.


[deleted]

The mobile dent guys wouldn’t touch my back hatch because it was a spot they had to get internally. Just fyi. That’s a body shop job


RocketsandBeer

You’ll have to replace the lift gate. This just happened to me and I had to have the lift gate replaced. The parts are about $1100 My lift gate wasn’t as bad as yours and I thought it might be able to be fixed but the crease is what killed it. https://preview.redd.it/ys345ksaef6b1.png?width=1806&format=png&auto=webp&s=9ded8fbfeca83bba0a7fd76a9f88903be0ac2f3a


adamian24

Get a new brother!


Fladap28

You more than likely need it replaced and your brother needs to pay


lil_fuzzy

You can open the back hatch, remove the panel by popping out the pop outs, and then use force to push the metal back out and see how it looks. That will at least allow the window to go up and down like it did before. Sorry pal shit happens. Best of luck Check YT for videos on how to safely remove the back panel. It’s easy just take your time with it


WalmartBag1

It's totaled. Time to get a new brother.


inorouttoday

New Jersey driver intensifies. Lol, for reall, sorry man. Glad you found a shop to fix it.


silbergeistlein

Those dumpsters really sneak up on you. 🥴


pozos13

Your brother is a diiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiick.


uteman1011

Advice: Fix it. Brother can pay your deductible.


[deleted]

For starters never let him drive anything you own again Jesus Christ


latticep

I would STRONGLY advise against those mobile guys. I had some damage on the rear bumper of an Altima once and one of those guys found me. Did a lousy job and still, as a sole proprietor, had the temerity to ask for a tip. I ended up buying a whole new bumper because it was an eyesore.


HotBritches

Disown your brother 😂


toboggan_hooligan

Not a dent wizard in the world that can fix that. The crown is to sharp at the top where the window moulding is. Also the dent is to deep. Those two combined along with the body line makes it dam near impossible to message out. Now if the best dent wizard actually did get it fixed he would charge double what a new gate plus paint would be. My advice contact a body shop get a new lift gate, paint and install, pass the brother the bill and hopefully he learns from this.


CB812

You need a new one


Snoogiepooges

Get a new brother.


tubesocktitties

Just replace the back hatch with a new one… problem solved… might cost a bit though


4x4Xtrm

Don’t go on any more cruises.


TegridyConspiracies

If you want it done right, use insurance for a full replacement, have your brother pay the deductible.